zeepadEverybody’s coming out with tablet gift buyers’ guides this time of year (including us in not too long). I thought it might be a good idea to come out with more of a thinking guide, something to suggest ideas for you to consider while you read those guides—a “buyers’ guide guide” if you will. These are the primary considerations I think a tablet buyer should be keeping in mind.

1) Walled garden or the open road?

Many of the most popular tablets this year are locked up in someone’s walled garden. The iPad and iPad Mini are no-brainers in this regard, of course, but there are also the Kindle Fire and the Nook Tablet. Though these devices are Android at the core, they use their respective backers’ customized interfaces and hardware, and as a result are largely limited to walled-garden stores. In some cases you can jump through hoops to add external apps that may not even work right to begin with, but you’re mostly limited to what they want to give you and that’s that.

On the other hand, devices like the Google Nexus, Kobo Arc, Galaxy Tab, Insignia Flex, Zeepad, or the Visual Land 7” tablet Best Buy is offering for $80 as an online-only Black Friday deal use plain-vanilla Android (though the Arc, at least, does have its own custom interface that sits on top of it). Android isn’t as polished as iOS yet, but the biggest advantage it does have is the ability to sideload apps from all sources without any jailbreaking required. Do you want to throw that away to restrict yourself to what only one store can offer?

Well, depending on how invested you are in a particular walled garden already, perhaps you do. Fortunately, the major e-book stores largely aren’t a consideration for this, at least where tablets are concerned. If you were foolish enough to go heavily into Apple’s iBookstore, you’re basically locked into iOS, but all the rest have e-reading apps suitable for most portable platforms, including either iOS or Android—though sometimes Amazon or B&N may make it tricky to load direct competitors’ apps on board their own tablets. (But if you’re looking at dedicated e-readers rather than just tablets…yeah, you’re basically out of luck unless you crack the DRM as a matter of course.) Likewise, music largely isn’t an issue anymore either, since most of the big e-music stores don’t DRM their music at all.

But if you’re looking at streaming media, sometimes it’s more of an open question. Netflix has players for most major platforms—but Amazon Prime’s own streaming media system has a Kindle Fire and an iOS app but no generic Android app yet. And special services like the Kindle Owner’s Lending Library are only available to people who own Amazon hardware.

Of course, if you’re mainly looking for a tablet as a way to surf the web and check your email and social networks, perhaps none of this matters. They can all do that pretty much equally well.

2) Capabilities vs. Budget

There’s no denying that tablet prices have fallen to an amazing extent in the last few years, to the point where tablets with decent speed and storage can be had starting at $200—or less. Of course, the iPads cost more, in some cases a lot more, and some of the tablets such as those from Barnes & Noble have arbitrary limits on how much onboard space you can use for your own content vs. how much can be used for theirs—but on the other hand many Android tablets have the ability to add additional storage to the chips inside them via inserting a SD or micro-SD card—even the cheap-as-dirt 4GB Zeepad. The iPad can’t do that.

Even the cheapest of the cheap low-end tablets, like the sometimes-annoyingly-slow Zeepad, are still tablets, with all the mobile Internet access that tablets have to offer. (And even the cheapest, like the $90 Zeepad, can s     eem to afford capacitive touchscreens these days.) If you can’t afford anything better, you can get by with that. On the other hand, if you can afford better, you might just want to shell out a little bit more.

3) 7” vs 10”

So where do you stand on the usefulness of the 7” form factor? Steve Jobs famously complained it was neither small enough to hold in one hand like an iPhone or iPod Touch, nor large enough to show a useful amount on the screen and allow for easy touch typing. It was just…awkward. But that hasn’t stopped Apple from coming out with its own 7” tablet now that others have pioneered the form factor, of course.

I’ve had a 10” first-generation iPad for some time now, and a 7” Zeepad for a few days, and I’ll admit they have different uses. The Zeepad is small enough to hold in one hand for extended periods without my hand getting tired, for one thing—a big consideration in deciding on a tablet for my one-handed mother. And it’s small enough to fit in a hip or even back pocket (though I don’t recommend the latter if you’re going to be sitting down) at need. (I was able to carry it with me for use at a wine tasting where there would not have been room for my iPad plus keyboard on the table.) For the iPad, you need at least a shoulder bag. But on the other hand, you get a much better picture and a bigger view with a bigger tablet—especially one of the Retina Display iPads.  It depends on what you want to use it for.

And who knows, you might not even necessarily need even a 7”. I saw someone on the bus today with a 5” Galaxy Note, and it was a really impressive little thing. Even a 4” iPod Touch could be all the e-reader or tablet you need in many situations.

4) WiFi vs. 3G/4G

All tablets these days come with built-in WiFi, but some have built-in 3G or 4G—and in some cases the cellular Internet plans will even permit you to tether other devices to them. Sometimes the fees are fairly reasonable, with month-to-month pay-as-you-go schemes and no contracts. And if you’re only ever planning to use that tablet, or to carry it everywhere, that might be best for you.

For myself, I have always felt that built-in cellular Internet in a tablet was not useful, at least inasmuch as it raises the price of the tablet itself over the WiFi-only version. In all cases I know of, these devices can only be used with one particular service provider, and if you don’t want to use it with them, tough, you’ve already paid the extra money. And if you’re tethering other devices to it, do you really want to have to carry something the size of a tablet around with you to be able to u

se them?

By comparison, a pay-as-you-go MiFi can sit in your pocket and net-connect any device you want, from an iPod Touch up to a laptop computer, meaning you can leave the tablet at home if you need to and still take something smaller with you for getting online—or take something larger with you if you’re going to be getting seriously busy.

5) Other Features

There will be things I haven’t mentioned that will be important to you, of course. Does it come with a stylus? Does it have Bluetooth? A camera? Two cameras? And of course you should think about those. But generally speaking, anything that passes muster in the criteria listed above will probably be good enough in the rest.

Are there any important criteria I’ve left out? Let me know in comments.


  1. Convenience in sideloading content is one issue for me – one that tilts me to Android every time. Sure, these days most non-DRM files can be downloaded straight from the cloud to your machine. But I want a completely accessible file system where I can copy and shift around things as I like, and one that doesn’t require me to carry around a special USB cable to link to other machines. Android tablets win out on this. Apple’s closed file system is an obnoxious instance of DRM within the OS, putting companies’ interests before those of consumers. Oh, and not to mention sticking to your own proprietory connector to reap fat licensing fees.

    For size, 7″ is the way to go for an ereader. 10″ is just too big for most people to carry for the extended time you need to read books. If you want primarily to play games or watch videos, then the tradeoff may be different.

    Budget is really becoming a key issue, though. I mean, why pay more for less? That’s the question the Nexus 7 is posing to tablet lovers everywhere. Unless you really need a feature that the Nexus 7 doesn’t have (size, SD card, back camera, etc), it’s the obvious choice.

    [reasonably] happy Nexus 7 owner here.

  2. Apple is a walled garden. The iBookstore is the most closed of any closed store. I never shop there. I love the iBooks app though. However, iOS is the most open walled garden. You have access to every major closed store via each store’s app without having to do any hardwork. No one else is that open. Android doesn’t have a monopoly on side-loading. I’m an iOS user and 99% of my ereading is done via side-loading. I almost always chose DRM free ePub. I’m very picky about how my library is set up so Calibre has been a godsend. I have 3 easy ways of side-loading my content.

    1: I can have Calibre send books directly to iTunes. Then I can sync.
    2: I can download books direct to my devices via Mobile Safari from Calibre’s content server if I’m not near my computer or I’m away from home.
    3: If I buy a new book from an open store such Smashwords or Robot Trading company I can just download the book directly like in scenario 2.

    Capabilities are far more in important than price for me. I’m a cheapskate, but I’m also a believer in the ‘You get what you pay for’ philosophy. I’d rather not have any device at all than to have one that will give me more hassles than enjoyment. Some, but not all, tablets just plain suck.

    I aways choose the 3G/4G model iPad. It’s just more convienient. I don’t want to carry or charge an extra device. As for size, until last Tuesday, I would have said go big or go home. But after a hands on with the mini I found it to be very nice. But I have a physical disability so I can’t hold any device that’s bigger than my iPhone for any longer than carrying it from one room to another. The mini would be easier, but I’d still need my PadPivot stand. At that point I might as well stick with the full-size iPad. With that said I would’ve walked out of Sam’s Club with the mini if it had a Retina display.

    Chris, you should check out the PadPivot. I think you can still get the old version at BestBuy for under $10. http://www.padpivot.com

  3. I agree with Jessica’s line of thinking. It doesn’t seem accurate to tie the closed garden concept to any tablet hardware. It’s the DRM that closes the garden and necessitates different eReaders. On iOS, you may have several of these closed gardens (Kindle, Nook, etc.) and a couple of open gardens (unencumbered eBooks readable on almost any eReader and via the web as in Ibis Reader).
    The storage factor is another questionable criterion. With iCloud for iOS, Calibre’s built-in eBook server and the WWW (think Internet Archive, Feedbooks, etc.), one can access a sizable eBook collection without futzing around with highly loose-able cards and chips.

  4. Yeah, I own an iPhone 4S, and while it’s *beautiful*, and I love Apple’s larger-scale computers, I would (if I were in the market for a tablet) hesitate long enough to examine my options before going for an iPad. It’s not the content walls that bug me, but the application walls. I don’t appreciate being told that I can’t use any program I please on hardware that allegedly belongs to me.

The TeleRead community values your civil and thoughtful comments. We use a cache, so expect a delay. Problems? E-mail newteleread@gmail.com.